We go to Temptation each June and December and still pay generally the same amount since my first trip in 2006...it was still Blue Bay Getaway then. We’ve been to the resort two times on Referrals and spent two hours each time giving their sales presentation a good faith try. Everyone values different things about their vacation...so to say whether membership is a “good deal” or not depends completely on what you value, how and how often you vacation and your other financial obligations. We go in low season twice a year and find good package prices on each trip. The membership black band perks don’t have a lot of value to us...at least they’re not something I’d pay more for. There would have been no value in purchasing a membership based on what we value. We have many friends who love the value the membership brings them because of what’s important to them.