We have gone on the Captain Hook Dinner Cruise and we got completely hammered. It is all-you-can-drink and the drinks were very good. Doug even participated in one of their drinking contests and won a bottle of tequila. It is a good time, there were no kids on the boat we were on. It would definitely be a change up from Temptation if that is what you are looking for.
We did one in St. Lucia in late December. Ship was crawling with kids........and then the kids were given water pistols. What could go wrong there???? Was ready to walk the plank. Great for families, but we will never do it again. Looking forward to our first Boobs Cruise though!!