Fixed it for you. You'd added it as a profile pic, you also need to add it as an avatar pic to get it to show next to your posts.
I can honestly say that nobody came up to me and said, "Hey John, there you are" from my barbaric pic of my hoisting Stacia around as our profile pic. ..... quite a few recognized Stacia from behind though, hmmmm...
Funny.. similar thing happened here. Not 10 minutes by the pool and we received "Kelsey??". Twice. No word of a lie. Perhaps I'm not as memorable from this pic. lol.
My original pic Duffman, and once I went out in costumer he was instantly recognized. No one knew who I was though unless I had the Duffman hat on, so that worked out nicely. It was because of this site though that people knew I was from the website and introduced themselves. Then I saw Duffman in Jamie's book and realized it is a great idea to have a pic of you on here so others can recognize you. You might not even realize it, and you ask if they're from CancunCare and the conversation is started. Now I have made many friends down there, and many more on here since and can't wait until next year!