This may be the third time I've answered a "what should we wrestle in" question this month... Weird... ANYWAY... I've done both jello & oatmeal. Jello is cold and uncomfortable & can dye your skin if you pick the wrong color- no one wants to be green at paty o's. maybe "wrestler's jello" is different, but I was not a fan.... Oatmeal is actually pretty nice- makes hair & skin SUPER soft, but I'm not sure of the logistics at TTR...we got a bag of oats from the feed store (yep, the stuff you give horses) and ran a hose off the hot water heater to get the hot water to make it oatmeally. -c
All I can think is please no Ready Whip lol. The only time I tried playing with that stuff it started to smell like vomit and that was the end of that fun time until we could scrub down in the shower.