We will have to try GP Then. I agree on crappy service and food at TTR. Only reason to ever go back is the ppl.
No comparison....TTR. You'll never regret it. Not to mention you will probably never be able to go to another "vanilla" resort again. My 2 cents.
I will start by saying I have never been to TTR. With that I said I have a trip report posted on this forum that gives my thoughts on GP. In brief the food and service is the best I have enjoy at any AI resort. Days at GP is a little tame but not boring at all. Plenty of drinking, pool games and I saw some day time hot tub action. At night it gets wild at Tiki bar and hot tub. I guess if you want non stop party go to TTR. If you want great food, service and beach with a fun night life (but not crazy as TTR) go to GP. I think GP depends on who is at GP at same time as you. We went during Spring break and had some respectful Spring Breakers that helped.
There is absolutely no way you will be disappointed with Temptation. The atmosphere and the people cannot be beat. I'm 33 and we're about to embark on our 4th trip and each one keeps getting better!