Negril. Realistically All inclusives need to be where there is cheap labor - thus Mexico, DR and Jamaica have most of them
Being from Houston, we sort of like TTR where it is in Cancun! 1 hour, 51 minute flight! Boo-Yah! Remember, those of you who'd like it to be on the west/Pacific coast of Mexico, there WAS a Temptation AND a Desire over there in Cabo for a while, and the clientiele did not support the resort adequately to justify it staying open for a while, so... that's kind of shaky ground. I understand they're trying it again, so we'll see. IMO the DR isn't nearly as hospitable as Mexico, the culture isn't the same. BIG difference between the level of hospitality on "Island Time" and in Mexico. Mexico kicks ass.
Cabo again would be great. Only problem though is now we nearly always go with groups of friends from all over so getting one resort picked would be tougher than having no choice. If there was a cabo one again though we'd do 3 or 4 day trips down there way more often. Vegas would be fun but just like the rest of vegas it would likely end up way expensive to the point you could just shoot down to cancun for the same $.
We're with you on Cabo. We enjoyed that location and the size of the TTR there. San Jose also has a vibrant artist community.